PCB Design Challenges: A Package Designer’s Perspective


Reading time ( words)

The challenges faced by the PCB designers of today are significant. If we examine the breadth of designs, we find ever-increasing data rates and more high-speed signal routing that drive additional challenges meeting signal-quality requirements, including reflection signal loss and crosstalk issues. At the same time, designers are being asked to complete designs in shorter cycle times and in smaller form factors. They must come up with new and more complex routing strategies to better control impedance and crosstalk. Manual implementation is often time-consuming and prone to layout errors. Designers have an increased need for pre-layout simulation to evaluate the design early on and establish routing strategies.

Designers are faced with conflicting requirements. The PCB designer is expected to do more with less space. The overall density of designs is increasing. Balanced against cost constraints, the PCB designer may leverage high-density interconnect (HDI) technology to compress the design into the available space, which in turn increases the likelihood of signal integrity issues. Cost pressures may force the PCB designer to reduce layer count or, at the very least, stay within the layer count that has been budgeted.

The PCB designer finds himself in a constant battle to converge on a design that meets all the design constraints. EDA vendors have provided a suite of various tools and automation to assist with the manufacturing constraints and physical and signal integrity physics of the design—breakout tools, route feasibility and estimation, timing and delay match, HDI-compliant design, and flex and embedded component design. Without a doubt, the challenges are significant for the PCB designer. If the constraints cannot be surmounted with technology, perhaps the solution is to work smarter.

So, rather than looking at some of the advanced additive technologies and other PCB manufacturing capabilities that could enable us to work at a significantly finer pitch, albeit at a higher cost, let’s focus on those capabilities that allow us to work smarter. As an IC packaging EDA engineer, I argue that working collaboratively with the system design and packaging engineers is one way we can enable denser designs that are completed faster, while still meeting signal integrity and power integrity requirements. Doing so requires more pre-planning and pre-analysis of the design, specifically looking at breakout patterns from the high pin-count devices, the critical signal typologies and routing schemes, and an up-front analysis of the critical signals within the design.

To read this entire article, which appeared in the August 2018 issue of Design007 Magazine, click here.

Share

Print


Suggested Items

PCB Designer Survey: Everything Starts With Design

04/25/2019 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
Recently, a variety of technologists who fabricate and assembly PCBs have made the following statement: “Everything starts with design.” We want to get your thoughts on this. What are some of the steps you take early in the design process that can affect your downstream partners? Let us know!

Putting University Training to Work

04/25/2019 | Nolan Johnson, I-Connect007
At a job fair on campus at George Fox University, Nolan Johnson sat down with Jake Whipple, a computer engineering senior, to discuss the GFU engineering program. This is one of the few engineering programs in the U.S. that gives students experience designing PCBs before they enter the work force.

An Experienced Millennial on Hiring the Next Generation

04/24/2019 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
During DesignCon, I met with Geoffrey Hazelett, VP of sales for Polar Instruments. Even though he has been in EDA for a few years, Geoffrey is still in his thirties, which makes him a youthful cherub in this industry. I asked Geoffrey what he thinks about the new PCB designers and EEs entering this field, and what more can be done to expose young people to the world of PCBs.



Copyright © 2019 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.