Sensible Design: Five Key Factors for Flexible Resins and Potting Sensitive Components

Reading time ( words)

Alistair Little mug.JPGIn my last column, I looked at how to select the appropriate resin for your requirement, bearing in mind that correct product selection is affected by the physical constraints of the board or area to be covered as well as other issues. In this month’s column, I am going to concentrate on protecting sensitive components and take a more in-depth look at flexible resins, their reworkability, and some of the common problematic consequences that you may encounter. Potting compounds play an important role in the electronics industry where they serve to protect sensitive components from chemicals, moisture, dust, and damage, but their selection can baffle many. Let’s explore some frequently asked questions in more detail.

1. What Are the Key Considerations When Selecting a Resin for Potting Sensitive Components?
There are many crucial factors to consider when choosing a suitable resin to pot sensitive components. First, you need to determine what temperature range is expected and look at the design, shape, and dimensions of the components. For instance, does a component have long thin legs that could be snapped off? It is also important to determine how large a volume of resin will be necessary to enable the degree of protection required.

Further, it is advisable to check the compatibility of the resin with the housing material. In the majority of cases, there aren’t any compatibility issues, but it's worth checking just to be safe. Examine how dense the component layout is on the board and consider how well the resin will flow across the board. It is worth noting that lower viscosity resins flow better; however, a thixotropic resin might afford more control to obtain the desired coverage. Does the resin need to flow under components, and, conversely, should it not flow in certain areas? Also, consider whether the resin needs to be flame retardant; if so, to what approval level?

The end-use environment is another key factor not to be overlooked. Consider what environment the finished unit will be exposed to as this may be harsh, which will also affect that resin that is most suitable. In turn, this will define whether the resin needs to provide primary or secondary protection against it.

You might also need to protect electrical or electronic components that are likely to come into contact with chemicals, including acids, alkalis, solvents, and a whole raft of other substances that pose a threat to delicate circuits and components. Chemical resistance is very much the province of epoxy resins, though some of the tougher polyurethane products as well as some silicone-based formulations will provide a degree of protection, particularly against moisture/water ingress. Epoxy resin products are available to protect electrical/electronic units that undergo frequent or permanent immersion in solvents, such as diesel fuel, leaded and unleaded petrol, and cellulose thinners.

2. Can Resins Be Dug Out/Reworked If Necessary?
The simple answer is yes; there are specialised 'dig-outable' resins available for use. These are primarily aimed at development and prototyping projects where easy access to components is required. Generally, they have poor chemical resistance and physical properties, particularly in terms of strength and toughness.

However, in the case of more general resins, it is possible to remove cured resin from around components and areas on a PCB, but these require either the use of a solvent or cutting away the resin from the area of interest. The hole can then be refilled with some more freshly mixed resin, but this leads to a potential weak spot in the resin coverage as chemicals and water could penetrate through the resin interface. Similarly, thermal cycling/shock could cause the interface to weaken and become exposed. Both polyurethane and silicone resins are more easily removed for rework purposes, and special solvents are available to assist with this process.

3. What Are the Possible Implications of a Resin Being Unable to Maintain Flexibility at Low Temperatures?
Normally, the main reason for a resin to lose its flexibility is due to brittleness. This can be due to a number of factors, but at low temperatures, the most likely reason is that the resin approaches or passes through its glass transition temperature (Tg). This is the temperature at which a resin goes from a brittle or glassy state to a rubbery state. The effect upon the components/PCB is that they will experience increased levels of physical stress, which might lead to components being broken and/or legs being snapped. In worst-case scenarios, even the PCB itself could be broken.

4. What Are the Consequences of Leaving Contaminants on the PCB Before Encapsulating?
Prepare for contaminant warfare! If a resin is applied to a PCB that is still covered by contaminants, then the resin will adhere to the surface of the contaminant rather than the PCB substrate or the surface of the components. Therefore, if there is a failure of adhesion between either the resin and the contaminant, or the substrate and the contaminant, then this will introduce a point of weakness in the resin-substrate interface, which could allow other contaminants to attack the PCB/components.

The contaminants may directly attack the PCB/components or induce an attack. For example, if a piece of solder is left, bridges across the copper tracks or across two component legs, and is then covered in resin, this increases the severity of the attack and prevents removal of the contaminant. Ultimately, leaving contaminants on a PCB before encapsulation could lead to shorting and will result in the premature failure of the unit.

5. What Are the Consequences of Taking in Too Much Air When the Resin Is Being Mixed?
Taking in too much air during mixing can cause a whole world of pain; however, this is a very common problem. The incorporation of air into the resin is to be avoided at all costs, as excessive air can lead to a lower-density material being created. In the case of mixing machines that dispense by volume, this means that there is insufficient resin being applied once the air has been released during the pouring and initial curing time of the resin. If the air is trapped in the final cured resin, this can lead to premature failure of the resin due to voids being created, which are weak spots, particularly for thermal and physical shock. The actual resin thickness applied will be lower than it appears, resulting in potentially lower performance and premature unit failure.

If the cured resin containing entrapped air is subjected to pressure or vacuum, the resin could rupture, exposing the PCB and components to the atmosphere. If the void created by the trapped air is directly next to a component or copper tracks, it acts as a concentration point for static charges to be built up. In certain applications, this can reach an energy level that is powerful enough to punch its way through the resin layers to ground itself and cause a short circuit. I can’t emphasise enough how important it is to give very careful attention to the prevention of air entrapment.

Future Columns
When it comes to discussing the choices, applications, and protective properties regarding resins, there’s a great deal more to cover. In my future columns on resin systems, I hope to provide some useful tips and design advice that will help you achieve the highest level of circuit protection whilst guiding you through the pitfalls and pain points that are best avoided to prevent shorting and premature unit failure.

Alistair Little is global business/technical director—resins—at Electrolube. To read past columns from Electrolube, click here. Also, visit to download your copy of Electrolube's book, The Printed Circuit Assembler's Guide to… Conformal Coatings for Harsh Environments, as well as other free, educational titles.


Suggested Items

Material Conservation: The PCB Designer's Role

09/01/2022 | I-Connect007 Editorial Team
During these times of supply chain uncertainty, many product developers are considering new ways to conserve materials—from laminates to components, layer reduction, and everything in between. Barry Matties and Happy Holden recently spoke with Alun Morgan, president of EIPC and technology ambassador for Ventec, about material conservation strategies for today’s PCB designers and design engineers. Alun explained why this may be the perfect time to educate PCB designers about conserving materials: When a model is broken, the people involved are much more open to new ideas.

Designing for Material Conservation Means Changing Attitudes

08/29/2022 | I-Connect007 Editorial Team
It makes a lot of sense: During times when the supply chain is stretched to the breaking point—and the last few years certainly qualify—what if PCB designers created boards that used fewer components and less laminate? Do PCBs still have to be 0.062" thick? Why not reduce layer count while they’re at it? Andy Shaughnessy and Nolan Johnson spoke with I-Connect007 columnist Dana Korf about the idea of designing a PCB with material conservation in mind. Is it a great new idea, or are we opening a whole new can of worms and a separate group of problems?

Design Tips for Lowering Costs of Fab and Assembly

08/25/2022 | Cherie Litson, CID+, Litson1 Consulting
This is the million-dollar question of every project: How can I cut the cost of the PCB? There are about a thousand answers to this question. There are a few simple guidelines that everyone can follow to reduce costs. I talk about them in my IPC CID and CID+ courses. Designers, fabricators, and assemblers talk about them in a variety of articles. Some professionals who have published some great articles on cost-saving strategies include Tara Dunn, Happy Holden, Chris Church, Kella Knack, Judy Warner, Julie Ellis, Lars Wallin, and many, many others.

Copyright © 2022 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.