NPL/SMART Group Conformal Coating & Cleaning Experience


Reading time ( words)



From a design point of view, it was necessary to carefully consider component layout, especially if dip coating was specified, to avoid features such as open through-hole vias, and to add tooling holes appropriate to the application method. The essential elements of a conformal coating drawing were definitions of: cleanliness requirements, areas to be masked and method of masking, conformal coating type, application method, thickness specification and inspection standards.

A good crowd gathered to hear Phil Atkinson of Fraser Technologies put his perspective on the need for cleaning before conformal coating. Having outlined the general benefits offered by conformal coating: Protection against moisture intrusion, humidity, shock, vibration, and corrosion, as well as electrical insulation, he summarised the properties and relative merits of the range of coatings available: Acrylics, urethanes, epoxies, silicones, and polyparaxylenes. There was no universal solution; it was a matter of intelligent selection in respect of performance requirements such as operating temperature, moisture resistance, chemical resistance, and whether formal qualification was required.

Why clean? He described the surface of a PCB assembly as a “chemical residue soup” which, before lead-free, did not generally present a significant problem and most conformal coatings could be successfully applied directly without cleaning. However, as technology had progressed with tighter packing densities, higher operating frequencies, and higher power, coating without cleaning was not recommended. Lead-free had been the real game-changer, with higher process temperatures and more tenacious residues, and he listed a whole range of contaminants that could be present--originating from the PCB and components as well as from the assembly process itself--and gave examples of failures that they could cause. In summary, he advocated that cleaning before coating was good practice, and recommended ionic cleanliness testing to prove its effectiveness. An appropriate cleaning process could promote optimum coating adhesion, whereas a poor cleaning process was the root cause of many coating defects.

The third presentation came from Willis himself, giving advice on selecting a coating based on product and environment. Why conformal coat? He listed several purposes: To prevent premature failure, to improve the performance of specific components, to improve environmental protection, as a possible alternative to a sealed enclosure to reduce the cost of the end product, and to ruggedize a product design. He then summarised the characteristics of available coatings and typical coating thicknesses. A golden rule was never to use conformal coating to overcome process problems by attempting to cover them up--it was vital to have a properly engineered and controlled assembly process in place before considering any conformal coating operation. He showed many examples of process and field failures, explained their causes, and recommended consulting the NPL Process Defect Database--freely available--as a point of reference to help identify and resolve problems.

Share

Print


Suggested Items

What Is Digital Twin Technology, and Why Is It So Important?

09/09/2020 | Happy Holden, I-Connect007
Happy Holden describes how Siemens' 12-part webinar series, “Implementing Digital Twin Best Practices From Design Through Manufacturing,” is an excellent series designed to educate the electronic manufacturing engineer on the progress of using a digital thread to improve products and performance.

This Month in SMT007 Magazine: Robustness Is Not the Same as Reliability

09/02/2020 | I-Connect007 Editorial Team
Bob Neves discusses a disconnect he sees in reliability testing between what’s being tested and what happens out in the field, as well as why most reliability tests these days should instead be considered robustness tests.

The iNEMI 2019 Board Assembly Roadmap

06/01/2020 | Pete Starkey, I-Connect007
iNEMI continues to publish chapters of its 2019 Roadmap and recently presented an overview of its Board Assembly Roadmap Chapter in a webinar prefaced by Grace O’Malley, vice president of global operations. The new chapter is just the latest addition to this global effort from 23 working groups contributing expert input from all aspects of the electronics industry.



Copyright © 2020 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.