A Review of the Opportunities and Processes for Printed Electronics (Part 3): Materials, Process Developments

Reading time ( words)

Most of the attention given to materials has appropriately centered on conductive inks, especially silver. Silver is the most conductive commonly used metal for making circuit conductors. Membrane switch circuits, which operate at relatively high voltages and low currents, have been printed onto polyester base materials using silver inks for more than a few decades. The challenge has been getting these circuits to have the bulk conductivity associated with copper. Common inks have conductivities that hover around 10% of copper and are not generally suitable for higher performance applications that operate at lower voltages or may require more power.

A number of suppliers have attacked the problem using a combination of new formulations of binders in the ink and nanoparticle silver are showing good improvements. One company, NovaCentrix, is addressing the challenge of making printable circuits by developing a tool and technology that sinters metal and semiconductor inks in a matter of milliseconds using light energy. The process reportedly can be carried out on a range of materials, including low-temperature, flexible substrates such as polyethylene terephthalate (PET) and paper. It is a promising technology for making low-cost products.

Ink technology

Organic and inorganic materials are both used for printed electronics. Ink materials must be available in liquid form for solution, dispersion or suspension. They must function as conductors, semiconductors, dielectrics or insulators. Material costs must be appropriate for the application.

For printing, viscosity, surface tension and solid content must be tightly controlled. Cross-layer interactions, such as wetting, adhesion, solubility and post-deposition drying procedures, affect the outcome. Additives often used in conventional printing inks are unavailable because they often defeat the purpose of electronic functionality.

Material properties largely determine the differences between printed and conventional electronics. Printable materials provide decisive advantages beside printability, such as mechanical flexibility and functional adjustment by chemical modification (e.g., light color in OLEDs).

Printed conductors offer lower conductivity and charge carrier mobility. With a few exceptions, inorganic ink materials are dispersions of metallic microparticles and nanoparticles. P-type metal-oxide-semiconductor (PMOS) technology may be used in printed electronics, but not complementary metal–oxide–semiconductor (CMOS) technology.

Conductive inks have been available for at least 40 years. The new conductive inks are designed specifically for use with low-temperature substrates including paper, (PET), polyether ether ketone (PEEK) and other plastics (including polyethylene film) and cure in an air environment.

Table 1: Ink Technologies


Copper, tin and silver nanoparticles are used with screen, flexo, offset and inkjet printing. Gold, silver and copper particles are used with inkjet. Sheet resistance is as low as ten milliohms per square. Resistivity’s as low as four times bulk have been attained with silver, but are higher for copper inks.

AC electroluminescent (EL) multicolor displays can cover many tens of square meters, or be incorporated into small watch faces and instrument displays. They involve six to eight printed inorganic layers, including a copper-doped phosphor, on a plastic film substrate.

Nanotechnology is the greatest boon to PE inks. There are proprietary material comprised of silicon nanoparticles dispersed in an environmentally-friendly blend of chemicals. These have optimized silicon particle size and dopant concentration to maximize the conversion efficiency of photovoltaic (PV) cells. The ink is screen-printed and a lower viscosity is available for inkjet printing.

Carbon nanotube (CNT) is another nanotechnology. CNT inks are available from many suppliers and known as V2V Ink Technology. C3Nano has transparent conductive CNT ink for touch panels and solar cells.

Table 2: Nanoparticle Conductive Metal Inks (from Novacentrix)



Printed electronics uses flexible substrates, which lowers production cost and allows fabrication of mechanically flexible circuits. While inkjet and screen printing typically imprint rigid substrates like glass and silicon, mass printing methods nearly exclusively use flexible foil and paper. PET is a common choice due to its low cost and higher temperature stability. Polyethylene naphthalate (PEN) is another.

PEEK is a colorless organic polymer thermoplastic used in engineering applications. Polyimide (PI) foil is another alternative. Paper's low cost and manifold applications make it an attractive substrate, but its roughness and absorbency make it problematic for electronics. Low roughness and suitable wettability, which can be tuned pre-treatment (coating, corona) are important criteria for substrates. In contrast to conventional printing, high absorbency is usually disadvantageous.



Suggested Items

Catching Up With Sean McConville, Niche Electronics

02/22/2021 | Dan Beaulieu, D.B. Management Group
Dan Beaulieu catches up with Sean McConville, vice president of business development at Niche Electronics, who shares his background in the industry, the strengths of his company, and how the pandemic has affected its business.

Meet Christine Davis, I-Connect007 Columnist

12/23/2020 | I-Connect007 Editorial Team
Meet Christine Davis, one of our newest columnists! Christine will share her expertise and lessons learned through her journey as one of the few women in the electronics industry to found and run her own company.

Lorain County Community College’s Successful MEMS Program

12/07/2020 | I-Connect007 Editorial Team
The I-Connect007 editorial team had the pleasure of an extended and detailed conversation with Johnny Vanderford and Courtney Tenhover from Lorain County Community College (LCCC). Vanderford and Tenhover are at the heart of the microelectromechanical systems (MEMS) program at LCCC that is emerging as a model for a successful technical higher-education program. This conversation was lively, and the enthusiasm at LCCC is infectious, as it should be; their results are impressive.

Copyright © 2021 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.