Elementary, Mr. Watson: Location, Location, Location

Reading time ( words)

“Location, location, location” is the mantra of any good real estate agent. The belief is that a home’s value fluctuates and is directly connected to its location. Anyone who has been home buying knows it’s not mainly the home itself but preferably what surrounds it that determines the real worth, such as the neighborhood, the types of schools, or whether or not your neighbor likes to practice drums at 3:00 a.m. every day in their garage.

When it comes to PCB design, one of the most overlooked principles is component placement. Similar to a home, the component location has a considerable impact on the quality, and I would describe it as the real value of a PCB design.

Nothing else is more vital to your designs’ overall value, while impacting so many different areas, than component placement. Some would argue that the more tedious and essential process is the routing, but I would point out that the component placement determines the routing. I would go as far as to say that the routing begins with your component placement because a great PCB designer can visualize the routing paths while placing the components. Many PCB designers’ passion for their craft is how they look at a layout; it’s one giant puzzle for most. With each component that they place on the PCB, the ability to visualize the puzzle’s solution is a real talent.

Furthermore, the component placement directly impacts the PCB manufacturing cost. With electronic devices getting smaller, a significant challenge is to first place more into the smaller area, which comes with its inherent heat dissipation and many other problems. Secondly, what seems to be the ever-changing design for manufacturing (DFM) guidelines such as component solderability, all of it directly relates and starts with component placement.

With that in mind, let’s look at five rules to follow when it comes to component placement. Of course, this shortlist is not comprehensive, but it is a good start.

General Component Placement Rules

1. First Things First
When beginning your component placement, it is essential to start with the critical components first, then large components, and finally, supporting discretes. A critical component is any component that impacts the overall unit form, fit, or function. These can range from board-to-board connectors and any components that require user access to the “outside” world. The mechanical function of your product entirely depends on your critical component placement.

Once that is done, a common practice is to lock their positions down. Next on your list is the larger components with their supporting discretes.

2. Grid, Grid, Grid
One of the standard rules throughout your PCB design is the importance of grids, including keeping certain items on the grids starts with the schematic symbol when placing the pins on the grid and keeping the schematic symbol on the grid.

On the PCB, when placing the components, it is all about the grid. For the large component mentioned in Rule 1, you should use a 50- or 100-mil grid (1.25–2.5 mm). For the supporting discretes, SMT resistors/capacitors, or other small passive components, a grid of 25 mils (0.625 mm) will do just fine. With some of the even smaller discrete components now used in the high-density layouts, you may require a smaller grid.

3. Edge Clearance
Keep your components at least 100 mils (2.5 mm) away from the edge of the PCB. There are a couple of reasons for this. Primarily, with the PCB edge V-scoring, the cutter bit is a 30° slice into the PCB at least one-third depth on each side, leaving only the inner one-third called the web. The board edge clearance is required not to hit any components, which would cause considerable damage to both the board and the V-score bit.

You also want to keep that component clearance from the PCB edge when the V-score is either cut or snapped. That is a highly stressed area. If you are snapping the V-score, the components close to the edge will stress the components, solder pads, and joints. These are the sort of problems that occur in a design that may not show up at first. But after being in the real world environment with conditions, power cycling, and thermal conditions. Those problems started with merely placing a component to close to the edge of the board. When they raise their ugly head, you need to make a field service visit. That is not a good image you want to make to your customer.

4. Circuit Isolation
An important rule in PCB design is to know your circuit and divide it into its operational sections, such as the analog, digital, and power supply areas. When designing the circuit, a good electronic engineer will have the analog and the digital circuitry isolated with its power and ground requirements. Also, use circuit isolation components. That is a subject of its own, especially when discussing the grounding (return paths) for the isolated circuits.

But with your placement, identify and keep isolated the analog, digital, and power components, ensuring that these separate areas do not cross-over each other and have their individual places to operate on your PCB. The reason being that each of these circuit types has its unique and specific noise and EMC problems that have a significant impact on the other circuits.

5. Components on a Single Side
Try to place all components on the top side only. IPC Standard IPC-2222 (1.6) describes the two assembly types of boards as being Type 1 as being the assembly with components on a single side and Type 2 as an assembly with components on both sides of the board. These are broken down even further into classes of the types of components used (SMT/TH). The reason for such detail in the types and classes is the necessary assembly processes needed on a PCB. It’s essential to understand those various assembly processes and how it impacts the design for assembly (DFA).

If not possible to keep all the components on a single layer, then only place the low-profile, small-size, and low thermal dissipation component (like SMD passive parts) on the bottom side.

Finally, having through-hole components placed on both sides of the PCB is not recommended. That is a complicated and expensive assembly process. But I am sure some assembly houses would take up such a complicated process for the right price.

The author Napoleon Hill once said, “Plan your work and work your plan.” That could not be more true than when walking through the various issues of a PCB design, especially when speaking of your component placement. Know your plan to correctly place the design components and never be in a guessing game; in the end, this will ensure you the best finished product.

John Watson, CID, is a customer success manager at Altium.



Suggested Items

DFM 101: PCB Materials

04/30/2021 | Anaya Vardya, American Standard Circuits
One of the biggest challenges facing PCB designers is understanding the cost drivers in the PCB manufacturing process. This article is the first in a series that will discuss these cost drivers (from the PCB manufacturer’s perspective) and the design decisions that will impact product reliability.

Karen McConnell: Recipient of the IPC Raymond E. Pritchard Hall of Fame Award

03/11/2021 | Patty Goldman, I-Connect007
"I heard about IPC when I started a new job at UNISYS after graduating college. I moved from ASIC design to printed circuit boards," said Karen McConnell after being inducted into the Raymond E. Pritchard Hall of Fame. "At the time, in the late ’80s and early ’90s, there were rumors going around that printed circuit boards were going to disappear, and ASICs were going to take over the world. But something in printed circuit boards fascinated me. I minored in robotics in college as an electrical engineer and the data used to fabricate, assemble and test the boards is actually all robotic language. I was hooked."

Cadence’s Celsius: Don’t End up Holding the Hot Potato!

12/17/2020 | Clive "Max" Maxfield, Maxfield High-Tech Consulting
I was just thinking about the party game Hot Potato. It reminded me of today’s increasingly competitive marketplace: Accurate thermal analysis must be performed, and any potential issues have to be identified and addressed as early as possible in the design cycle. Otherwise the system will run into problems, market windows will be missed, and someone will be left holding the hot potato. Trust me, you do not want to be that someone.

Copyright © 2021 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.